Prospecting guide
Find the people who need it now.
How founders and salespeople decide who to reach, find them and build a list worth writing to.
The short version.
- Start with people you know. Your first two or three customers almost always come from your network. 1
- Write one sentence about who has the problem, then pick the group that needs a fix right now. 2
- Narrow until you could name 30 companies today, and write to the person whose job the problem is. 3
- Give every first message a reason to write now that you can link to: a job post, a funding round, a public complaint. 4
- Check every email, keep one sheet and test small groups before you scale. 5
Start with people you know.
Your first customers are probably one introduction away.
Customers one through three almost always come from your personal network.
Kolysh asked dozens of YC founders how they found their first ten customers. An early buyer is betting on a new company, so they need to trust the founder, and the people who already know you trust you most. 1 The founder stories Lenny Rachitsky collected say the same: Gusto’s first ten “came from friends we knew who were just starting their businesses in California.” 6 Prospecting tools, Kolysh says, “only start to matter once you have 10 to 20 quality customers.” 1
Borrow a network for an hour. Ask an investor or advisor to go through their LinkedIn connections with you, and paste anyone at a company that fits into your sheet. Pete Kazanjy, author of Founding Sales, says it takes an hour or two and “will invariably be worth it.” 7 Then make each introduction easy: say who you want to meet, why they’d care and what the connector can forward.
Decide who needs it first.
Choose on urgency, not market size.
Pete Koomen, a YC General Partner and Optimizely’s co-founder, starts with a sales hypothesis: “customer X has problem Y, and our product will help them solve it.” A good one “makes prospecting easy by clarifying who you should be talking to.” 2 Then ask Paul Graham’s question: “who wants this right now?” 8 YC’s partners put it in numbers: “recruiting 10 customers who have a burning problem is much better than 1000 customers who have a passing annoyance.” 9
Watch for the trap Koomen calls out: talking to whoever will take the call. It “selects for the people who are easiest to talk to, not the people who will be great customers.” 2 Keep a group only if they have the problem today, fixing it is someone’s job, they’re already patching it with a spreadsheet or a hire, and you can spot them from the outside.
Narrow it until you can list it.
Add one filter at a time until you could name 30 companies today.
Sometimes the right unscalable trick is to focus on a deliberately narrow market.
- Software companies
- Series A SaaS in the US
- …with 3+ account executives
- …hiring their first RevOps lead
- Their VP of Sales
Try the 30-name test. Open a search tool and list 30 companies that fit. If your description won’t turn into filters, rewrite it with things you can see, like a size band, a place, a tool they use or a job they’re hiring for. Then choose the person whose job the problem is, not the one who’s easiest to reach. Kazanjy’s check: “If the person in question can say, ‘Well, that’s not really my job,’ then you know you have the wrong person.” 3
Find a reason to write now.
A sign you can see, with a link, tells you who needs it this month.
Christina Gilbert, a YC Visiting Partner, calls these intent signals: clues that a company needs what you make, like a job post or fast growth. 4 My rule: nobody gets a first message without a sign, the date you saw it and the link. The best ones are recent and tied to your problem: hiring for it, a new leader, a fresh round, a public complaint, a post about it.
- Retool filtered Crunchbase by “when was the last time the company fundraised and what verticals they’re in,” kept operations-heavy startups and emailed “the CTO and VP of operations.” 6
- Vanta “emailed anyone who’d ever said the word ‘compliance’ on Bookface in the prior decade.” Bookface is YC’s internal forum. 6
- Optimizely checked whether prospects ran “analytics tools and JavaScript frameworks,” signs that a company cared about its website. 2
Every product has signals like this. Your job is to discover yours.
Find them, and check every email.
Search by title, size and sign, then verify every address before it goes on the list.
Kolysh’s first question, before any tool or channel: “Where does your target customer actually spend their time?” 1 For buyers at a desk, two tools do most of the work. Apollo “was the most common starting point” for the founders Kolysh asked, 1 and Koomen says many in YC’s Winter 2024 batch used Apollo and LinkedIn Sales Navigator. 2 Search by job title, seniority, company size and place, then narrow to people who changed jobs or posted lately, or companies that are hiring. For developers, look where they work in public: GitHub and Hacker News.
Check every address. A bounce is an email that can’t be delivered, and too many hurt your sending for everything after. Amazon’s email service tells its senders, “For best results, you should maintain a bounce rate below 2%.” 5 Run a couple of email finders in turn, put everything through a verifier, and set aside catch-all domains, which ZeroBounce says can’t be validated “without sending a real email and waiting for a bounce.” 11 Guessing is fine if you check: if everyone at a company is first name dot last name, Aaron Epstein, a YC General Partner, notes you can probably guess anyone’s address there. 12
Keep one sheet, and test small.
One row per person with a reason to write and a next step. Then read the replies.
| Name | Role | Company | Why now (source) | Fit | Status | Next step | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dana Reyes | VP Sales | Northwind | Hiring a first RevOps lead (job post, Oct 14) | A | Verified | Meeting booked | Call Thu 10:30 |
| Omar Haddad | Head of Sales | Brightline | Raised a $14M Series A (Oct 2) | A | Verified | Replied | Send two times |
| Priya Raman | VP Revenue | Kestrel | Posted about messy CRM data (Oct 19) | A | Risky | Sent | Follow up Oct 31 |
| Leo Martins | Sales Director | Tally | New in the role since September | B | Verified | Ready to write | Draft message |
Plan on hundreds, not dozens. Gustaf Alströmer, a YC General Partner: “you cannot close five customers from 10 leads.” His example funnel starts with 500 messages and ends with about 10 calls and 2 customers. It’s an illustration, not a benchmark, but it shows the scale. 13 For a first test, run two to four groups of 100 to 200 people, each a different kind of company or sign, and count replies and calls, never opens.
Even just two to three replies on 100 emails is a great place to start iterating.
Ask everyone who books a call what made them answer, and reuse their words. Gilbert: “Your customers are always going to write better copy than you do.” 4 Then rewrite your one-line target, drop the weakest group and run the next hundred.
Rather have River build the list? See what River does for prospecting