Cold email guide
Cold email people answer.
How founders and salespeople set up sending, write short emails about the reader and follow up.
The short version.
- Send your first 100 or so from your own mailbox, each written for one person. 1
- When you send more, move the sending to separate domains and keep every inbox at a low, fixed number a day. 2
- Who you email and what you offer matter more than the wording. Fix the list and the offer first. 1
- Under 75 words, plain text, about them, with one easy ask. 3
- Follow up two or three times with something new, answer replies fast and include a way to opt out. 4
Start from your own mailbox.
Your first hundred emails need a simple setup: you, your work address and one person at a time.
most cold emails are actually terrible, so the bar is really low for you to stand out
Christina Gilbert, a YC Visiting Partner who closed millions of dollars in founder-led sales at OneSchema, recommends doing at least your first 100 by hand, so you learn who replies and why. 1 Pete Koomen, a YC partner and Optimizely’s co-founder, says the same: “Start by writing each email by hand.” 5 At tens of emails a day, each written for one person, your main domain is fine.
- Send as yourself. Epstein: the From line “should just be your personal name.” 4
- Check every address before you send, and keep bounces under 2%. 6
- Plain text, like a note to a colleague. Gustaf Alströmer, a YC General Partner: “Write your email in plain text only, like you would write it to a friend.” 7
- Keep one sheet: who you emailed, when, what they said and who asked you to stop.
Protect your domain when you send more.
Hundreds a week through a sending tool is when to move off your main domain.
Your main domain carries your company’s everyday email. Separate sending domains keep its reputation “from being damaged if your emails are marked as spam,” as Clay’s deliverability guide puts it. 2 It’s an afternoon’s work.
- 2–3 separate domainsgetacme.com, tryacme.com. Each redirects to acme.com.
- Inboxes in your nameTwo or three per domain, on Google or Microsoft.
- SPF, DKIM, DMARCThree DNS records that prove the mail is yours.
- A sending toolA few dozen a day per inbox, plain text, no tracking.
- Their inboxA short, personal email from a real person.
Your main domain, acme.com, stays out of campaigns. Its reputation carries your everyday mail.
- Two or three lookalike domains, like tryacme.com, each forwarding to your real site. 2
- Inboxes in your own name on Google Workspace or Microsoft 365. Nick Abraham, who runs the lead-generation agency Leadbird: “Always use Google or Microsoft accounts - most trusted and stable.” 8
- Three settings that prove the mail is yours. SPF lists the servers allowed to send for your domain, DKIM signs each email, and DMARC tells inboxes what to do when a check fails. Gmail asks every sender for at least SPF or DKIM. 9
- A low, fixed number a day per inbox, with nothing tracked. Abraham: “Plain text-only. No open tracking, links, or attachments.” 10
Stay under the spam line. Gmail asks every sender to keep spam reports below 0.3% and ideally below 0.1%, and to never buy lists: “Don’t purchase email addresses from other companies.” 9 Relevance keeps complaints down more than anything else.
Lead with the offer.
What you offer matters more than how you word it. Make it about their result.
Gong, which sells sales software, analyzed more than 28 million cold emails and found that “Pitching reduces reply rates by as much as 57%.” 11 Gilbert’s version: executives don’t care that your database is built in Rust; they care about hitting their quarterly target, so she keeps the product explanation to one sentence. 1
Great offers > great personalization. A 10-step Clay workflow will not save a mediocre offer.
Abraham’s formula: “The best offers have a quantifiable end result, risk reversal, and social proof.” 13 In plain words, a result they can picture, less risk for them and a name they know. Size it to where you are. With nothing to sell yet, ask for advice, but only if you mean it. With a product, offer something useful first, like a short audit, and then ask for 15 minutes. And for business customers, Alströmer would skip the free trial: “Go for a money-back guarantee and go for the ability to opt out instead.” 7
Write it like you’d say it.
Under 75 words, about them, one ask. If it sounds like a template, rewrite it.
- A short subject about their world. A few words, lowercase is fine. Epstein’s examples: “Hey quick question,” “Can I get your advice.” 4
- Open with them. A dated fact about their company, not your name and title.
- One line of proof. A customer they know, or why you of all people understand the problem.
- One ask, on its own line. About 15 minutes by phone or video, or a yes to something you’ll send.
- Under 75 words. That’s the limit Max Kolysh, a YC Visiting Partner, and Abraham both use. 3 13
Make it impossible to send to anyone else. Abraham’s test: “never send a cold email (for yourself or your client) that can be sent to another person and still make sense.” 14 Then read it out loud. Kolysh’s one-minute test: “Find a friend and just read your email out loud to them.” 3 Koomen’s rule sums it up: “only send emails that you yourself would be excited to read.” 5
Learn from real examples.
Two emails from people who send a lot of them, with what each line does.
Follow up, test and stay legal.
Most replies come after the first email. Answer them fast.
Follow up with something new. Epstein: “you should plan to manually follow up two, three, four times as needed,” with a few days between emails. 4 In Smartlead’s data, one email earned about 12 replies per 1,000 people and a three-email sequence about 25. 6 Keep follow-ups in the same thread, add a finding or a resource each time, and never write “just checking in.”
Answer within the hour. In the same data, 64% of replies arrive within an hour, 6 and Gilbert wants founders to be “like a heat-seeking missile” once someone replies, because “time kills deals.” 1 Offer two specific times rather than a booking link.
Test the list and the offer, not words. Split your next few hundred people into two to four groups of 100 to 200 with a different audience or offer, and judge by replies and meetings, never opens. Gilbert: “Targeting beats perfect messaging.” 1
Know the legal basics. In the US, CAN-SPAM covers business email too: an honest From and subject line, your postal address and a clear way to opt out, honored within 10 business days. 15 The EU, UK and Canada are stricter about who you can email, so check before you write there. This isn’t legal advice.
Rather have River do it? See what River does for cold email