Thorncastle Instruments v. Bellweather Forge · Exhibit Register
Every number on the joint list, and the answer next to it
Illustrative rows from a fictional casting failure matter. Bellweather is the defendant supplier and trial is six weeks out.
| Ex. | Description | Produced | In 26(a) | Sponsor on a list | Disposition | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TX-051 | Photographs of the failed housing, undated | No | No | None | Moved in limine | 37(c)(1) |
| TX-088 | Supplier scorecard covering four vendors | Yes | Yes | Iyengar, on neither | Moved in limine | 901(a) |
| TX-103 | Redesign drawing issued after the recall | Yes | Yes | Aldworth | Moved in limine | 407 |
| TX-014 | Internal quality memo, second casting lot | Yes | Yes | Aldworth | Objection reserved | 803(6) |
| TX-171 | Email chain on the March pricing dispute | Yes | Yes | Hollings | No objection | |
| BW-601 | Settlement note to the third supplier | Yes | Yes | Marsom | Withdrawn 14 Mar | 408 |
The three middle columns are the ones nobody else has
TX-051 and TX-088 are unremarkable on their faces. One is a photograph and the other is a scorecard, and reading either tells you nothing. They are motions because of what is missing from the production log and the witness lists, which is a fact about two other documents.
| Disposition | Exhibits | Share |
|---|---|---|
| No objection | 209 | 50.7% |
| Objection reserved for trial | 123 | 29.9% |
| Moved in limine | 63 | 15.3% |
| Withdrawn after the meet and confer | 17 | 4.1% |
| Joint list, every number accounted for | 412 | 100% |
An empty disposition cell is the failure this sheet exists to prevent. 412 exhibits inside a 14 day objection window is 29.4 a day, weekends included.